The Raiders’ recent signings of cornerbacks Tarell Brown and Carlos Rogers got me thinking: Is Chris Culliver available?
No, that’s not right. What it got me thinking about were players who had suited up for both the Raiders and 49ers. Fanatics in either camp treat the opposite side of the bay as football Siberia, but less partisan sports fans and writers take some interest in guys who have traded the red-and-gold for silver-and-black, or vice-versa. And really, there have been a lot of those crossovers – enough, in fact, to fill out starting lineups.
In selecting the best at each position, I accounted for overall greatness, but I tried to pick guys who had made an impact on both teams. Thus, no Nnamdi Asomugha or Andre Carter. And Raiders fans, you’ll be happy to note that I’m penciling in Tarell Brown and Carlos Rogers for greatness (or at least goodness), with apologies to Marquez Pope and the late Dave Waymer.
Ladies and gentlemen, I present the Oaklancisco Forty-Raiders’ All-Time Team:
QB: Jim Plunkett
RB: Roger Craig
RB: Charlie Garner*
WR: Jerry Rice
WR: Randy Moss
TE: Ted Kwalick
OL: Kwame Harris
OL: Barry Sims
OL: Jeremy Newberry
OL: Ron Stone
OL: Kevin Gogan
DL: Cedrick Hardman
DL: Archie Reese
DL: Dana Stubblefield
DL: Ted Washington
LB: Bill Romanowski
LB: Matt Millen
LB: Riki Ellison
DB: Ronnie Lott
DB: Tarell Brown
DB: Carlos Rogers
DB: Rod Woodson
K: Joe Nedney**
KR: Terry Kirby
*If you think a team needs a fullback, you can go with Tom Rathman
**Sorry, Joe, you’ll have to punt, too.
Finally, we must offer a special tip of the cap – one of those ugly baseball caps that are half-49ers, half-Raiders, of course – to linebacker Keith Browner. He played exactly one career game with San Francisco and one with the Los Angeles Raiders – in the same year, the 1987 strike season. That’s a local commute that may never be duplicated.